What if we turned source evaluation from the CRAAP test into a pirate adventure where the whole narrative was the lesson? Avoiding a Pirate TRAAP is an original OER narrative that shows what happens to two teenagers who buy the wrong information from a man named Blackbeard Joe. Join me as we look at narrative pedagogy and discuss how to teach source evaluation and information literacy with ancient pedagogy techniques - from the fables of Aesop to the parables of Jesus - as we remix storytelling and learning to make the experience both fun and tangible. We will also discuss using the Adventurfy Method, an instructional method created by Lian Warner, on creating your own learning experiences that add adventure, risk, and story. Participants will gain access to the Pirate TRAAP story and a launchpad on how to create instructional adventures in your own library.